№ 0117 Alegação Em aberto Em alta Reino Unido
Está a ler o original (English). Mostrar tradução

137 of the 142 NHS trusts live on the Palantir-supplied Federated Data Platform are realising benefits from it, as NHS England's figures say

NHS England, Federated Data Platform (Palantir) · fonte original

NHS England's September figures list 142 hospital trusts as live on the Federated Data Platform (FDP), supplied by a Palantir-led consortium under a £330 million contract, and 137 of them as "realising benefits"; Palantir's UK executive Tom Watson repeated the numbers in a letter to an MP around 1 October 2026. In early November the campaign group Medact published freedom of information answers in which 29 trusts on that list said the platform was not live or that they used none of its applications. NHS England replies that the platform is available to every trust, which picks the tools it needs, and that 137 trusts have reported benefits; according to the Guardian, as summarised by The Next Web, it has since taken the list off its website. What would settle it: the trust-level benefits data NHS England promised the statistics regulator it would publish, showing for each trust which tool it uses and what benefit was recorded. The government is due to decide in December whether to continue the contract.

Provas

Provas de que é verdadeiro

50%
A favor Artigo

NHS England's reply: the platform is available to all trusts, and 137 have reported benefits from its tools

Asked by The Register (3 November) about the 29 disputed entries, an NHS spokesperson said the FDP is "universally available for all NHS trusts and integrated care boards", that local organisations select individual tools, and that "137 NHS trusts have now reported benefits" from those tools. On this reading the count rests on what trusts reported, not on full operational use; the reply does not explain what the disputed trusts reported.

theregister NHS counts Palantir benefits at trusts that say they're not using it Medact flags 29 disputed entries as ministers weigh £330M deal's future
footnote_hunter ·
– · 0 classificações Peso 24

Provas de que é falso

50%
Contra Registo oficial

Statistics regulator (July 2026): FDP benefit figures are before/after observations and cannot show cause and effect

The Office for Statistics Regulation's statement of 22 July 2026 says NHS England publishes two kinds of FDP "benefits": counts of actions users take in a product, and before/after comparisons for which it "cannot draw conclusions about cause and effect". NHS England agreed to label such figures clearly and to schedule publication of trust-level benefits data. The statement predates the September list and does not rule on the 137 count.

Office for Statistics Regulation NHS England Federated Data Platform (FDP) – presentation and communication of information and performance metrics - Office for Statistics Regulation In recent weeks, the Office for Statistics Regulation (OSR) has been contacted by several members of the public and journalists regarding NHS England’s presentation and communication of information and performance metrics informed by the Federated Data Platform (FDP). The concerns raised with us hav
Marginalia ·
– · 0 classificações Peso 32
Contra Artigo

FOI answers: 29 trusts on the "realising benefits" list say the platform is not live or not used

Novara Media (2 November), citing Medact: 29 trusts listed as "realising benefits" said in FOI replies that the FDP "is not live" or that they were not using any of its applications. That is about 21% of the 137. Medact campaigns against the contract, but the replies come from the trusts themselves. So which tools are these 29 benefiting from?

Novara Media NHS Claims Palantir’s Tech Helps Hospitals That Are Not Even Using It 29 NHS Trusts supposedly “realising benefits” from the Palantir platform have said the system is not live or that they are not using any of its applications.
wait_what_now ·
– · 0 classificações Peso 24
Contra Artigo

NHS England has removed the page listing 137 trusts as live and realising benefits

After the FOI story, the page with the list was taken down, as the Guardian reported and The Next Web summarised. Taking a page down is not a correction, and it does not say which number was wrong. Has NHS England published a replacement figure?

TNW | Uk NHS England reportedly deletes misleading Palantir benefits list NHS England deleted its list of 137 trusts said to benefit from Palantir’s data platform after 29 said they barely use it, as a contract extension looms.
wait_what_now ·
– · 0 classificações Peso 24