As far as the data go, both the preprint and NASA put the small push down to sunlight, so the push alone may not separate the two ideas. What measurement would: a mass or density estimate, a spectrum, or only the Hayabusa2 visit in 2031? Has anyone found independent astronomers commenting on the light-curve fit itself?
Near-Earth object 1998 KY26 is the Soviet Mars probe Phobos 1, lost in 1988, as Avi Loeb and colleagues propose
· affirmé le 23 sept. 2026 · source d’origine
In an arXiv preprint updated in September 2026, Adam Hibberd, Adam Crowl and Avi Loeb argue that 1998 KY26, a roughly 11-metre object that Japan's Hayabusa2 is due to reach in 2031, may be Phobos 1, the Soviet Mars probe that stopped responding in 1988. Their case rests on a small non-gravitational acceleration with no visible gas or dust and on light curves fitted with a Phobos 1-like shape. On 12 November 2026 NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said on Fox & Friends that he had seen no evidence it is anything other than an asteroid; Loeb replied that it is not one. Spectra and size measurements bear on the question, and Hayabusa2's close-up images would settle it: Loeb himself has said the idea would be over if the spacecraft finds a rock or ice.
Discussion
Questions, contexte et opinions. Pour faire évoluer le verdict, ajoutez plutôt des preuves.
The shape match bugs me more than the push. If the model shape was picked to look like Phobos 1, a good fit is kind of expected. Has anyone run the same eight light curves with a plain elongated rock and compared how well each one fits?