№ 0138 Claim Open France
Translated automatically from the original (Français). The original is the binding text. Show original

Despite "Lycée 4.0" (€310M since 2019), baccalaureate success rates in Grand Est are no different from those of regions without free computers

Grand Est Region, "Lycée 4.0" scheme · claimed on Nov 13, 2026 · original source

On 13 November 2026, the Grand Est Regional Chamber of Accounts (CRC) published a report on "Lycée 4.0", the Region's policy of giving a laptop to every pupil entering seconde and replacing paper textbooks with digital ones. According to press reports, the CRC puts spending at €310 million from 2019 to 2025, acknowledges that the scheme reduces inequalities in access to digital technology, but notes that the baccalaureate pass rate is no different from that of regions that do not distribute computers, and that the Region has never assessed the effects on schooling. Regional Vice-President Valérie Debord announces an assessment expected between December 2026 and early 2027. A comparison of how results changed before and after 2019 with comparable regions would make it possible to settle the question.

Evidence

Evidence that it is true

63%
For Article

France 3: according to the CRC, the Grand Est baccalaureate pass rate "is no different" from that of regions without the scheme

According to France 3 Grand Est (13 November 2026), the report judges that the scheme's educational effectiveness "remains to be proven" and that the baccalaureate pass rate is no different from that of regions that do not offer computers. The cost is about €41 million a year, €310 million over seven years; 45% of the teachers surveyed say they use these computers frequently, 40% "only from time to time".

France 3 Grand Est "Des effets sur la réussite scolaire à démontrer" : un rapport revient sur l'offre d'ordinateurs aux lycéens par la région Grand Est Un rapport de la chambre régionale des comptes pointe le manque d'évaluation du dispositif "Lycée 4.0" offrant un ordinateur portable à chaque élève de seconde du Grand Est. Une mesure pour réduire les inégalités qui coûte...
PiecesJointes ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 24
For Analysis

Bac 2025: 91.4% pass rate in the three Grand Est academies, versus 91.6% nationally

Calculation based on the 2025 results table by academy (all baccalaureates combined, source indicated: data.gouv.fr): Nancy-Metz 21,683 passed out of 23,509 candidates present (92.2%), Strasbourg 17,981 out of 19,554 (92.0%), Reims 12,031 out of 13,501 (89.1%). Total: 51,695 passed out of 56,564 present, i.e. 91.4%, versus 91.6% for all of France (682,001 out of 744,412). The gap with the average is small, smaller than the gap between academies within the region itself. Limitation: a single year says nothing about the scheme's effect without the series from before 2019.

Vacances Scolaires Résultats du Bac 2025 par académie : taux de réussite, mentions et classement | vacances-scolaires.com Les résultats du baccalauréat 2025 sont tombés : avec un taux de réussite national de 91,6 %, cette session confirme la stabilité des résultats. Découvrez le détail par académie, par voie (général, technologique, professionnel) et l'analyse des tendances marquantes. Tableau de synthèse — Résultats d
a_verifier ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 18

Evidence that it is false

37%
Against Article

87% of pupils surveyed by the CRC believe the computer makes their learning easier

Economie Matin reports that, according to the chamber, 87% of pupils surveyed judge that the tool "makes their learning easier" and that the purchase and distribution costs for 2021-2024 are in line with those of comparable regional schemes. This declared benefit is not necessarily visible in the baccalaureate pass rate, the only outcome indicator cited in the comparison; the chamber speaks of an "uncertain" effect, not a null one.

Economie Matin Lycées du Grand Est : 310 millions d’euros pour le numérique, des résultats encore mal évalués La chambre régionale des comptes chiffre à 310 millions d’euros les dépenses du dispositif d’équipement numérique des lycéens entre 2019 et 2025. Elle souligne un accès généralisé aux ordinateurs, mais un effet sur la réussite
PiecesJointes ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 24
Against Article

In 2023, the President of the Region considered that "Lycée 4.0" had "proven its worth" and refused an independent evaluation

In a letter of 25 May 2023 responding to two collectives of parents and teachers, Franck Leroy considered digital technology in the classroom beneficial and asserted that evaluation "takes place in real time and continuously" through exchanges with headteachers and parents. He added: "We are not authorised to carry out a study of this kind", referring the educational effects to the Éducation nationale. The Region's position therefore rests on field feedback, not on a measurement of results.

Rue89 Strasbourg Le président de la Région Grand Est estime que le lycée 4.0 a "fait ses preuves" Interpellé par deux collectifs sur les risques du lycée 4.0, le président de la Région Grand Est Franck Leroy exclut toute évaluation du dispositif et
Contrechamp ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 24