№ 0131 Claim Open Hot
Translated automatically from the original (Polski). The original is the binding text. Show original

The Işıldaktepe Altı mound on the Dardanelles is the original tomb of Ajax described by ancient authors, as proposed by an archaeologist from the Troy Museum

Işıldaktepe Altı, tomb of Ajax, Troad · claimed on Apr 30, 2026 · original source

On 30 April 2026 Fecri Polat published an article in the Troy Museum journal (Troy Museum Journal, TRMuseum) in which he describes the Işıldaktepe Altı site on the shore of the Dardanelles, discovered in 2011 and until now considered a prehistoric settlement destroyed by the sea, as a tumulus following excavation, and considers it in the context of the tomb of Ajax known from ancient texts. On 12–16 November the article was reported by the media in several countries. The identification is supported by the location and the accounts of ancient authors about a tomb on the shore. Against it: no finds have been described that would link the mound with Ajax, there is no precise date of construction, and the tomb of Ajax has traditionally been regarded as the tumulus at İn Tepe. Dating the mound's embankment and examining its undisturbed core would settle the question.

Evidence

Evidence that it is true

52%
For Document

TRMuseum article: after excavations Işıldaktepe Altı was recognised as a tumulus, not a settlement

According to the article's summary (Polat, TRMuseum, special issue of the IV Manfred Korfmann Troad Symposium, pp. 22–41), the site discovered in 2011 during surface surveys was described as a settlement largely destroyed by the sea. Only excavations revealed what it really is: the author writes of the "realization of its true identity as a tumulus following excavation works". He compares this mound with the tradition of hero tombs in the Troad, especially the tomb of Ajax, and relies on direct quotations from ancient sources (the bibliography includes Strabo, Pausanias and Philostratus).

dergipark.org.tr IŞILDAKTEPE ALTI KURTARMA KAZISI VE AİAS TÜMÜLÜSÜ BAĞLAMINDA DEĞERLENDİRİLMESİ Troy Museum Journal | Sayı: Prof. Dr. Manfred Osman Korfmann IV. Troas Sempozyumu Özel Sayısı
kwerenda ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 30

Evidence that it is false

48%
Against Article

Commentary: the identification rests on location and ancient texts, and the mound has no precise date

According to the commentary, the excavations did not show that anyone was buried here as Ajax: only the place and the writers' accounts link it with him. It is only known that the embankment was built after the Late Bronze Age. The article also does not explain how the new candidate relates to the mound at İntepe, which is usually regarded as the tomb of Ajax.

La Brújula Verde Archaeologists from the Troy Museum believe they have found the tomb of the Homeric hero Ajax On the Turkish coast of the Dardanelles — the strait in northwestern Turkey that separates Europe from Asia — just steps from the water, the sea has exposed a cross-section of earth about seven meters (23 feet) high. For years, it was interpreted as the remains of a very ancient settlement that wave
Zgrzyt_w_danych ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 24
Against Article

The tumulus at İn Tepe has traditionally been regarded as the tomb of Ajax, and Virgil places the tomb of Deiphobus in Rhoiteion

The entry on Rhoiteion identifies the mound at İn Tepe in the western part of the city's territory as the tomb of Ajax, restored according to Philostratus by Hadrian. In Book VI of the "Aeneid", however, the empty tomb at Rhoiteion belongs to the Trojan prince Deiphobus, so the tradition about this place is not uniform.

en.wikipedia.org Rhoiteion - Wikipedia
skądinąd ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 24