№ 0129 Claim Open

A 2026 DNA study confirms that the Shroud of Turin passed through the Middle East

Shroud of Turin · claimed on Apr 1, 2026 · original source

On 1 April 2026 Vatican News reported that new DNA research on the Shroud of Turin, led by geneticist Gianni Barcaccia of the University of Padua and then available as a preprint, confirms the cloth's passage through the Middle East. The study used material taken from the Shroud in 1978 and, according to IBTimes UK, was published in Scientific Reports on 9 July 2026. It reports several human mitochondrial lineages, including H33, alongside skin microbes and salt-loving archaea, and its authors also discuss a possible Indian origin of the linen. What would settle the claim is whether any of the DNA can be shown to be old and tied to a time and place of contact, rather than to later handling.

Evidence

Evidence that it is true

50%
For Article

Vatican News: haplogroup H33 and halophilic archaea point to a stay in the Middle East

The report quotes the authors: H33 is "prevalent in the Near East and frequent among the Druze", and halophilic archaea "indicate conservation in a saline environment or storage under saline conditions". Vatican News reads this as a sojourn near a place like the Dead Sea; the study itself speaks of individuals who interacted with the cloth across "various regions, populations, and eras".

vaticannews.va New DNA research confirms Shroud of Turin's passage through the Middle East - Vatican News The Holy Shroud of Turin passed through the Middle East, reveals new DNA research in the scientific article authored by Dr. Gianni Barcaccia, ...
footnote_hunter ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 24

Evidence that it is false

50%
Against Document

2015 study by the same group: the DNA mix fits both a medieval European origin and a Near Eastern journey

The 2015 Scientific Reports paper found human mtDNA from many individuals (haplogroups typical of Western Europe, the Near East, Arabia and India, H33 among them) and plant DNA including species brought to Europe only after the Middle Ages, such as black locust. Its abstract says the diversity "does not exclude a Medieval origin in Europe" while being compatible with a route from the Near East.

PubMed Central (PMC) Uncovering the sources of DNA found on the Turin Shroud The Turin Shroud is traditionally considered to be the burial cloth in which the body of Jesus Christ was wrapped after his death approximately 2000 years ago. Here, we report the main findings from the analysis of genomic DNA extracted from dust ...
Marginalia ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 30
Against Article

Published paper: the dominant human DNA in three samples matches the professor who collected them

IBTimes UK reports that the dominant signature in three of the 12 samples matched the mitochondrial profile of the late Pierluigi Baima Bollone, who took them in 1978, with kinship analysis pointing to the same person or a first-degree relative. If the clearest signal is that recent, how are the Middle Eastern traces dated? The article notes that regional DNA "cannot establish when it reached the fabric".

International Business Times UK Turin Shroud DNA 'Jesus' Claim Hits a Snag: Strongest Match Points To Man Who Collected Samples A study of DNA from Turin Shroud samples found the strongest human genetic signature matched the scientist who collected them, highlighting the difficulty of identifying the cloth's original occupant.
saysWho ·
– · 0 ratings Weight 24